
Nicole Kelly
Two former roommates from Flemington have been indicted in the homicide and robbery of an 86-year-old man whose body was found last November by one of his children.
Rachel Atkinson, 27, was indicted on four counts of first-degree murder and one count of first-degree robbery, as well as the lesser offenses of burglary and weapons possession.
Nicole Kelly, the 29-year-old former roommate of Atkinson’s at the Hunter Hills Apartments in Flemington, was indicted on the robbery and burglary charges, as well as third-degree hindering apprehension and some of the weapons offenses.
The 13-count indictment, released Friday by the Hunterdon County Prosecutor’s Office, stems from the November homicide of Arthur E. Seiple, whose body was found two days later by a daughter inside his condominium in the Flemington South Estates development.
Authorities have said they believe Atkinson committed the homicide sometime between the night of Nov. 12 and Nov. 13 during a planned robbery.
Court papers indicate that Kelly acknowledged her role in aiding in the planning of the burglary and hindering Atkinson’s apprehension. Kelly’s involvement in the alleged plot is unclear, and police have said Atkinson was alone at the time of the robbery and homicide.
Police have also said Atkinson knew Seiple, a widower who lived alone, and had stayed at his home before. An affidavit states that Atkinson confessed to causing Seiple’s death in his home “and provided specific details of the crime establishing her personal involvement.”
Atkinson is in custody in the Hunterdon County Jail in Flemington in lieu of $500,000 cash bail while Kelly remains in the Somerset County Jail in Somerville on $50,000 bail with an option to pay 10 percent, officials said.
The women are being held separately under an unspecified agreement between the supervisors of both facilities.
Seiple’s naked body was found on his bedroom floor, his throat apparently slit and his head possibly smashed in, according to a 911 call to police.
The weapons listed in the indictment include a knife, hammer and statue.
Seiple, killed less than a month before his 87th birthday, has been described as a friendly and active man who still drove and hardly missed breakfast at a nearby McDonald’s. A Navy veteran and retired postal worker, he has four children and two grandchildren.
Recent Comments